As believers called to steward our families with wisdom and courage, we stand firm on the unchanging truth of Scripture: “Train up a child in the way he should go, and when he is old he will not depart from it” (Proverbs 22:6). Yet in our modern age, this divine mandate is increasingly under siege by overzealous state agencies like Child Protective Services (CPS). What begins as a noble intent to protect the vulnerable too often morphs into a tool of intrusion, stripping parents of their God-given authority and fracturing the bonds of family without due process or mercy.
At It Is Our Duty, we shine a light on these injustices, particularly here in Arizona, where the Department of Child Safety (DCS)—our state’s CPS equivalent—has faced sharp scrutiny for discriminatory practices and unwarranted interventions. Drawing from real-world stories across the nation, this post uncovers patterns of overreach that echo the biblical warning against those who “devour widows’ houses” (Luke 20:47). We pray these accounts stir righteous anger and renewed resolve to defend the family as the cornerstone of society, upheld by biblical principles in the public square.
🏥 Hospital Seizures: The Nightmare of Losing a Newborn Before You’ve Held Them
Imagine the joy of your child’s first cry, only to have it drowned out by the cold machinery of bureaucracy. In hospitals across America, parents are flagged as “unfit” by nurses or social workers for daring to question standard protocols—often without evidence of harm, and certainly without the due process enshrined in our Constitution. These seizures aren’t rare anomalies; they’re symptoms of a system that views parental choice as peril, not a right.
One heart-wrenching case unfolded in Illinois, where new parents Courtney Hill and James Holderman welcomed their daughter in 2019. After declining the routine Vitamin K shot—citing concerns over potential side effects and informed consent—the hospital alerted the Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS). Within hours, their newborn was whisked away to foster care, leaving the exhausted parents to fight a two-month investigation. No evidence of neglect was found, yet the trauma lingered. The couple later sued, arguing the policy classifying Vitamin K refusal as “medical neglect” violated their rights. Their story highlights a chilling policy that prioritizes compliance over family unity.
This isn’t isolated to the Midwest. In Texas, the 2023 saga of Mila Jackson exposed racial biases compounding CPS overreach. Chelsea and Adam Jackson, a Black couple, chose a home birth with a licensed midwife to avoid hospital interventions they viewed as unnecessary. When Mila arrived healthy but was later taken to the ER for jaundice—a common newborn issue—CPS swooped in, citing the home birth as “risky.” Despite no signs of abuse, their infant spent 23 days in foster care before being returned. The Jacksons’ ordeal drew national outrage, revealing how systemic distrust of non-traditional births disproportionately targets minority families. As one advocate noted, “This case underscores the disregard for Black families’ autonomy in maternal care,” a sentiment that resonates with Scripture’s call to “do justice, and to love kindness, and to walk humbly with your God” (Micah 6:8).
Closer to home in Arizona, such intrusions are alarmingly common. A 2024 Justice Department investigation found that our DCS routinely discriminates against parents with disabilities, launching investigations or removals based on outdated stereotypes rather than facts. Reports abound of newborns separated at birth after routine hospital visits trigger anonymous tips—sometimes as retaliation for seeking a second medical opinion. One Arizona mother shared her terror on social media: “My baby was taken away by CPS after giving birth in a hospital… sparking a discussion about the corruption and abuse of power within the system.” These stories aren’t just statistics; they’re echoes of Pharaoh’s edict to seize Hebrew infants (Exodus 1:16), a tyrannical overreach that God overturned through faithful parents like Moses’ mother.
Broader data paints a grim picture: Civil rights attorneys document “unwarranted removals” as a rampant violation, with families losing custody before they can even consult a lawyer. In another Texas incident, 5-month-old Mason Bright was removed after a minor fall was misdiagnosed as abuse, thrusting his family into a legal battle that eroded their trust in institutions meant to help. Parents, take heart: These violations often unravel in court, as seen when families successfully sue for unconstitutional seizures. Yet prevention demands vigilance—know your rights, document everything, and rally your church community as a shield.
🏫 Targeting Homeschooling Parents: “Educational Abuse” as a Weapon Against Faith
If hospital seizures strike at birth, CPS overreach in education wounds the soul. Parents, compelled by conscience to shield their children from curricula laced with ideologies antithetical to biblical truth—such as LGBTQ+ themes, Critical Race Theory (CRT), or content that mocks faith—are increasingly vilified. What was once a protected choice under the law becomes grounds for “neglect” reports, with homeschooling branded as “educational abuse.”
Consider the Tutt family in Texas, a devout homeschooling clan of nine whose nightmare began in 2014. After an anonymous tip alleged poor living conditions (later debunked), CPS raided their home, forcibly removing seven children despite evidence of a thriving education. The agency cited the homeschool setup itself as suspicious, ignoring the family’s compliance with state laws. For three agonizing years, the Tutts battled in court, enduring separations that tested their faith to the breaking point. “We were accused of everything under the sun,” the parents recounted, yet no abuse was substantiated. Their vindication came only after relentless advocacy from groups like the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSLDA), exposing CPS’s bias against non-traditional families.
This pattern repeats nationwide, often triggered by curriculum disputes. In recent years, as public schools incorporate books with LGBTQ+ characters—prompting Supreme Court battles over opt-out rights—parents who fully withdraw to homeschool face retaliation. A 2025 high court ruling affirmed parents’ religious right to excuse children from such lessons in Montgomery County, Maryland, but for those who choose homeschooling instead? The backlash can be swift. Anonymous reports to CPS accuse them of “depriving” education, reclassifying a fundamental liberty as maltreatment.
In Arkansas, Daryl and Tammy—a homeschooling couple—faced a knock at the door in 2022 after a spiteful complaint questioned their methods. Despite HSLDA’s swift intervention proving their curriculum’s rigor, the investigation dragged on, sowing fear in their home. Critics argue these probes aren’t about child welfare but control, punishing parents for rejecting “anti-faith content” that Scripture warns against: “Do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind” (Romans 12:2).
Even in Arizona, where homeschooling freedoms are robust, DCS overreach looms. Our state’s lax oversight can cut both ways, but when combined with hospital or school referrals, it amplifies risks for families fleeing controversial curricula—like those flagged in Maricopa County libraries for inappropriate materials. As one local advocate urges, “If you take your child to the doctor or… call for emergency response, you may find yourself under a DCS investigation.” This isn’t protection; it’s persecution, reminiscent of King Herod’s slaughter of innocents (Matthew 2:16).
A Call to Faithful Action: Reclaiming Our Duty
These stories of CPS overreach— from Tennessee-inspired refusals to Arizona’s discriminatory probes—reveal a system adrift from justice, preying on the vulnerable while ignoring true threats like the child pornography infiltrating school libraries we so often expose. Yet in the shadow of such trials, God’s Word offers unshakeable comfort: “The Lord is a stronghold for the oppressed, a stronghold in times of trouble” (Psalm 9:9). He who parted the Red Sea for His people will part the seas of red tape for the faithful.
Fellow Arizonans, let’s press our Board of Supervisors to reform DCS oversight, ensuring investigations honor parental rights and biblical family values. Share your testimonies, support HSLDA, and pray without ceasing. For it is our duty—not the state’s—to nurture the next generation in righteousness.
Sources and Further Reading:
